• X
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Contact us
  • Login
Safefood 360°
  • More Information
    • Solutions For:
      • Food Safety Management
      • Supplier Quality Management
      • Enterprise Food Safety
      • Audit Management 360
      • Business Intelligence Dashboards
      • Remote Working and Oversight
    • Technology
      • Software Modules
      • Platform & Data Security
      • Available Languages
      • Standards We Support
  • By Industry
    • Bakeries
    • Seafood Processors
    • Beverage Manufacturers
    • Pet Food & Animal Feed
  • Customer Stories
    • Testimonials
    • UK: Butternut Box
    • EU: Royal FrieslandCampina
    • EU: Hofseth
    • USA: Bluegrass Ingredients
  • Support
    • Technical Support
    • Professional Services
    • Customer Success
    • Education & Training
  • Resources
    • ROI Calculator
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
    • Datasheets
      • Physical Hazard Series
      • Chemical Hazard Series
      • Microbiological Hazard Series
      • Food Safety Management Series
    • Presentations
    • Ebooks
    • Tools
  • Blog
  • Company
    • About Safefood 360°
    • About LGC Assure
    • Contact Us
  • Demo Request
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
  • More Information
    • Solutions For:
      • Food Safety Management
      • Supplier Quality Management
      • Enterprise Food Safety
      • Audit Management 360
      • Business Intelligence Dashboards
      • Remote Working and Oversight
    • Technology
      • Software Modules
      • Platform & Data Security
      • Available Languages
      • Standards We Support
  • By Industry
    • Bakeries
    • Seafood Processors
    • Beverage Manufacturers
    • Pet Food & Animal Feed
  • Customer Stories
    • Testimonials
    • UK: Butternut Box
    • EU: Royal FrieslandCampina
    • EU: Hofseth
    • USA: Bluegrass Ingredients
  • Support
    • Technical Support
    • Professional Services
    • Customer Success
    • Education & Training
  • Resources
    • ROI Calculator
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
    • Datasheets
      • Physical Hazard Series
      • Chemical Hazard Series
      • Microbiological Hazard Series
      • Food Safety Management Series
    • Presentations
    • Ebooks
    • Tools
  • Blog
  • Company
    • About Safefood 360°
    • About LGC Assure
    • Contact Us
  • Demo Request
unannounced auditor

Unannounced Audits

in blog

‘Is there anybody there?’ said the Traveller, Knocking on the moonlit door’

The opening line of Walter De La Mare’s The Listeners captures perfectly the feeling I regularly got when as an auditor a number of years ago I was required to conduct unannounced audits on suppliers for a large food retailer. More on this in a moment… but in general, it was an interesting experience. Years before anyone even considered conducting audits on their suppliers without a prior appointment, this retailer had a policy of sending in the auditor at random times, without notice to see the actual conditions under which their products were produced.

The magic of unannounced audits

It was radical, it was disruptive and above all it was effective! As an auditor I learned more about the management of food safety in those years. I quickly understood that audits when unannounced, changed the nature of second and third party audit engagements, changed the direct relationship between parties and undoubtedly changed audit outcomes.

More recently we have seen the BRC provide an option for companies to opt in to unannounced certification audits while a large European food retailer has informed suppliers that all future audits will be unannounced. More and more we are seeing what many of us believe is the unstoppable move towards unannounced audits becoming the norm. The practical impacts of this remain an open question and are worth considering. Before we do this, let’s first take a look at why we are seeing this shift towards unannounced audits.

For years I have listened to the debate on this and the agreements for and against announcing audits in advance. Both camps made compelling arguments and I was often swayed by both. But as is usually the case with issues debated in the realms of principles and opinions – reality comes along and cuts across our passionate beliefs.

Recent food scandals and auditing

For this debate it was undoubtedly the Horse Meat Scandal and other recent international food safety issues. Regardless of our position on unannounced audits the meat scandal in particular highlighted weaknesses in the second and third party audit framework. Some of the plants at the center of the contamination issue were BRC certified and approved directly by large food retailers. Despite auditors regularly inspecting, visiting and certifying these operations the scandal was not detected or prevented.

Now let’s be clear. This is not to say that these plants were intentionally hiding anything or auditors ignoring evidence of fraud – they weren’t but that did not prevent national and international media questioning the effectiveness of certification schemes like BRC or retailer technical approval of suppliers. In short it damaged the credibility and concept of auditing as a food safety and quality management tool. They may have been somewhat separate issues but in the consciousness of the media and public they were closely linked. And for me the reason was simple! It was assumed that audits were an objective assessment of the conditions and controls in place at a specific moment of time i.e. day of the audit.

The public would be surprised to learn that the vast majority of these audits are in fact scheduled and announced in advance. For most people, professional or public, this undermines the validity and objectivity of audits and may produce an audit outcome not necessarily representative of actual conditions. Credibility is undermined. The horse meat scandal raised fundamental questions and the shift towards unannounced audits may represent one of the answers.

Challenges of unannounced audits

What about the impacts on suppliers? Let me take you back to Walter De La Mare’s The Listeners. One of the surprising impacts of unannounced audits was the company’s reaction when I presented at the door. I would estimate that in 25% of cases I was refused entry to the site. It wasn’t long before I felt very much the Lonely Travellerseeking the Phantom Listeners behind the door of the food plant. But such was the reluctance to grant me access to conduct the audit that one could only speculate why a food business would risk its relationship with a significant customer? There were penalties for refusing access. Nonetheless it happened regularly.

My own belief was that it was preferable to suffer the reaction from the retail buyer rather than have the actual conditions of the plant audited on that day. This would be the more cynical of my thoughts but it was undoubtedly the case. In other situations the Quality Manager was not present on site and without prior notification of my arrival that would be a legitimate reason. Another auditor from another retailer may have been on site already conducting an audit or production lines were not operating for maintenance.

Here we can see the practical impacts on both the company and the auditor in attempting to run an audit program without prior arrangements. Other impacts include an almost certain reduction in audit performance and outcome – at least for a period of time while companies adjust to the new regime. This may lead to more suppliers failing and being delisted causing buyers untold headaches in meeting consumer needs. On the upside (at least as far as certification bodies are concerned) more failed audits mean more re-audits which means more revenues. These are just some of the impacts and there are more. The most important question however is the benefit or otherwise of unannounced audits.

A strange kind of logic

I once put the question to a senior retailer technical auditor why were all audits not unannounced? The response was that if a company could not get its act together for an announced audit then it would be clear they were not capable of supplying safe food. This may be true but for me it was a little strange in terms of logic. It assumed a direct relationship between the company’s ability to prepare for a one day visit and the conditions of production the other 364 days of the year. Would an unannounced audit not do the same thing but also show you the actual conditions typical every day? And so the argument went on…

It’s just the right thing to do

My experience as the Lonely Traveller taught me that unannounced audits were infinitely more potent than announced. I know this because I have performed both types of audit on the same food plant and the differences were stark. If the objective of an audit is to determine the level of compliance at a moment in time then we must as a global industry embrace this new move towards unannounced audits. A tool which provides a true reflection of where we are is powerful in maintaining standards and driving improvement – something every food business wants.

The food business has a lot to do in the day and sometimes things are not always perfect. The auditor must also recognize this and not allow unannounced audits to become a hard cynical tool to catch companies out. Common sense and intelligent assessment of risk must underpin the unannounced audit. This will avoid a game of cat and mouse emerging and destroying the positive relationship between parties.

George Howlett

About the author

George Howlett is the CEO of Safefood 360° and one of Europe’s leading food safety experts. Before establishing Safefood 360° he worked at some of Ireland’s most prominent companies and brings the expertise with him. George also lectures in the MSc for Food Safety Management in the Dublin Institute of Technology.

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail
https://safefood360.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/unannounced-auditor.jpg 432 650 /wp-content/uploads/2015/04/sf360-logo.png 2013-07-27 18:36:212016-03-14 16:55:59Unannounced Audits
Recent
  • Radura Symbol 1
    An Introduction to the basics of Food Irradiation
  • Food Fraud 1
    Protecting Our Food: Effectively Tackling Food Fraud
  • Data security 1
    How we ensure trust and security in our software platfo...
  • The Hidden Costs of Food Safety Non Compliance 7 1
    The Costs of Food Safety Non-Compliance: How to Avoid Financial...
  • PDSA blog cover
    Using the Plan Do Study Act Cycle for Better Food Safety...
  • The Answer To Food Safety Digital Transformation Challenges
    The Challenges of Digital Transformation in Food Safety:...
  • SSO
    What is Single Sign On and why do we offer it?  
  • Alcoa Principles What can the food industry learn from life sciences
    Alcoa+ Principles: What can the food industry learn from...
  • Hero image 3
    Introducing Audit Management 360: Better Food Safety Au...
  • Webinar1 SPC 1058 530
    Unlocking the Power of SPC in Food Safety: A Webinar Re...
  • Webinar 2 Mastering Operational and GMP Auditing A Comprehensive Guide to Best Practices 1058 530
    Unveiling the Secrets to Mastery in Operational & GMP...
  • Safefood 360 is top performer on sourceforge in Summer 2023
    Safefood 360°: Top Performer Summer 2023 at SourceForg...
  • RISK Jun 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (June 2023)
  • RISK May 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (May 2023)
  • sf360 Single sign on
    Should I implement single sign-on (SSO) for food safety...
  • How do Chemical Hazards Occur in the food safety process 1
    How do Chemical Hazards occur in the Food Safety Proces...
  • RISK Apr 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (April 2023) by Safefood 360°...
  • How do Physical Hazards Occur in the Food Safety Process 1
    How do Physical Hazards Occur in the Food Safety Proces...
  • The high cost of Cross contamination in the food sector
    The High Cost of Cross-Contamination in the Food Sector
  • RISK Mar 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (March 2023) by Safefood 360°...
  • RISK Feb 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (February 2023) by Safefood 360°...
  • RISK jan 2023 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (January 2023) by Safefood 360°...
  • Novel Food Regulation
    Novel Food Regulation: EFSA versus FDA
  • RISK Dec 2022 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (December 2022) by Safefood 360°...
  • RISK Nov 2022 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (November 2022) by Safefood 360°...
  • Blog post image 13
    Complete Guide to Food Cooking Temperature Control
  • RISK Oct 2022 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (October 2022) by Safefood 360°...
  • Blog post image 8 1
    7 Ways Compliance Management Platforms Improve Operational...
  • 6 Ways
    6 Ways to Implement Preventive Measures and Controls For...
  • RISK sep 2022 report
    Food Safety Alert Update (September 2022) by Safefood 360°...
Popular
  • CCP PRP blog
    Understanding the difference between PRP, OPRP & CCP...
  • fsma harpc guidance
    The difference between HACCP and HARPC. A case of the Emperor’s...
  • Auditing
    New checklist available for TS ISO 22002
  • thanks for c360
    Thank you for Connect 360°
Comments
  • Barry ONeillThank you Cyril! Glad to hear you enjoyed it.31 October 2023 - by Barry ONeill
  • cyril periappuramExcellent presentation, Thank you for your contribution...27 October 2023 - by cyril periappuram
  • Gay KSend me info on what foods and drinks and water having MRA...20 June 2023 - by Gay K
  • AmrikDear Sanika , we want to use one line to be able to ...9 February 2023 - by Amrik
Tags
food safety food standard and legislation Implementation pandemic Professional Services Report RISK Risk Assessment Tool supply chain webinar

Archives

Frame 16

Safefood 360°, built by a group of food safety experts in 2010, is designed to tackle the real difficulties facing food-related industries by combining Food Safety Management and Supplier Quality Management Solutions with over 35 pre-set modules – creating a fast, secure, and audit-ready working environment.

Follow us
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to X
  • Link to LinkedIn

Solutions

  • Food Safety Management
  • Supplier Quality Management Software
  • StatusBI Business Intelligence
  • Audit Management 360

Support

  • Technical Support
  • Professional Services
  • Password Reset Instructions
  • Accepting an invitation from Safefood 360°
  • Frequently Asked Questions

Resources

  • Whitepapers
  • Technical Data Sheets
  • Webinars
  • Tools
  • Presentations
  • Privacy Policy
© Copyright – Safefood 360°
IT Solutions for the Food Industry – Seminar (Dublin, Ireland)AlertsNew feature “Alerts” will keep you updated
Scroll to top